Dungeon Mastering

DM Tools - CREATE YOUR FREE ACCOUNT       About Us       Contact Us       Advertise                   Subscribe to Dungeon MasteringSubscribe

The 5 Greatest Fears of DMs

Written by MythicParty - Published on October 8, 2012

’tis the Season for Ghosts, Goblins, & Things that go Bump in the night.  Or in this case of this month’s article, things that (metaphorically) go bump behind our hobby’s fabled cardboard screens.  Because although it may seem odd, there is indeed stuff that scares the person responsible for putting fear into players.  Here are the 5 greatest such situations:

FEAR #5 You’ll never get to play the game as a player.  ie. you’ll be stuck behind the screen from one long drawn-out campaign to the next long drawn-out campaign.

Don't end up stuck like Quicksand Cat.

Morale Bonus from deciding ahead of time roughly how long the arc will run & then whom else will be taking over the DM reins after you.  If it look like the campaign won’t end on time, not being afraid to call for a break.

FEAR #4 The game will be too easy/too hard ie. the characters will either find it to be a complete cakewalk or a TPK.

Damn Boosted Bugbears

Morale Bonus from setting mutual expectations as to what constitutes the age-old favorite guideline of “tough but fair” before the campaign starts.  Then don’t pull any punches for anyone by having the players roll all the dice (a variant seen in the 2nd incarnation of Unearthed Arcana) so they always know that the dice laid is a dice played.  No more of that dice-behind-a-screen, then-lift-up-the-screen-to-show-a-20 over dramatic BS.

FEAR #3 Your players won’t really enjoy the campaign

Every player always carries a torch.

Morale Bonus from regularly soliciting feedback & never asking them if they had ‘fun’ (gag) but rather a few key questions that will provide you with (actual) useful feedback.  Then, trying to adapt to what they’re asking for in a timely fashion.  If their request isn’t something you can provide then explaining to them why you aren’t able to meet that condition.  That way they know you’re listening as well as attempting to adjust.

FEAR #2 Eventually one of your players won’t like YOU or you won’t like them

"Don't make me angry. You wouldn't like me when I'm angry."

Morale Bonus from remembering everyone’s common goal, “We are building a story together. You can make assumptions about the situations and encounters your characters are in and my job is to go along with whatever you’re assuming unless it directly contradicts something that was already established.”  Also keying in on feedback to discern if anyone in particular doesn’t seem to be enjoying themselves.  Lastly, don’t be afraid to speak privately with someone you trust to see if they’ve heard anything table side.  Try to work it out as adults.  If it is you having an issue with a certain player, then the same holds true, just follow the process in reverse- explain to a player whom you trust that there’s a problem with someone in their group & see if they have any suggestions.

And the #1 FEAR… You’ll grow to hate the game itself or become so addicted to it that it sucks away all your time, energy, & money

"Well it WAS a 20."

It is incredibly easy to spend too much on materials for your game, whether is it making your own or buying supplied.  Come up with a reasonable budget & then stick to that.  If you do so, you’re far less likely to hate what your role, but if it turns out that you indeed do start resenting sitting behind the screen, its time to hand the seat off to someone else or at least switch to a Plan B until that relief person is ready.

Written by MythicParty

Dog-loving, movie-watching, pizza aficionado. Content Editor for DMing.com, Project Manager for AvatarArt.com, & player of the coolest characters in a weekly D&D game. Halflings are the real heroes.

If you’re interested in helping us out, a simple way is through our Dropbox referral:

Thanks for reading.

GD Star Rating
The 5 Greatest Fears of DMs, 4.4 out of 5 based on 5 ratings » Leave a comment



3 Responses to “The 5 Greatest Fears of DMs”
  1. Alan says:

    True enough what you say. Last weekend I was DM and I didn´t had fun, because everything became too sloppy and I thought everybody was getting bored. Rough night, man.

  2. Lokiare says:

    Really good info for new DMs in here. I even learned a few things about getting feedback. Good article…

  3. Kravaros says:

    Hey, as a starting DM/GM, I am afraid especially of #2: the game being too hard. As I am going to begin mastering my first campaign soon, Id like to know: whats the greatest EL a first level party of 4 can take on? 2? 3? 5?
    Can they defeat a 4th level cleric as the final boss? And can they be expected to survive an ambush with a caster, archers, and caltrops in a dark, narrow, hallway? Thanks.

 Speak Your Mind

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!